# Agent Review Checklist Use this checklist after `building_spec.json`, extraction audit, and overlay SVGs exist. ## Accept for Web Showcase Accept when: - Main floor outlines, walls, columns, beams, floor detail, and grid are visible in overlays. - Unclassified geometry is mostly annotation, dimensions, text, furniture, landscaping, or detail symbols. - High-risk `INSERT`/`HATCH` entities are either irrelevant or visually accounted for by extracted linework. - Blender preview is nonblank, correctly framed, and visually matches the floor-plan intent. - Web viewer loads with clean console logs and controls work. - Presentation/digital-twin views show readable slab edges from side views; floor plates do not disappear behind glazing. - Generated roofs use roof-floor footprints unless CAD evidence supports a canopy/overhang. - Ground/podium columns that have no upper plate plus nearby upper structure are shortened or documented as intentional. - Web delivery exposes overview, standard, and detail GLB downloads when lightweight variants were requested. State known gaps in the notes. ## Iterate Extraction Return to config or parser work when: - Red dashed overlay geometry forms obvious walls, columns, beams, grids, stairs, or slab outlines. - A large unclassified layer has high supported vector length and architectural names. - Frequent `INSERT` blocks likely contain architectural geometry. - `HATCH` or `SOLID` represents primary filled walls/columns and line extraction missed it. - Multiple floors are misaligned after overlay/Blender review. - Generated slabs are much larger/smaller than the true building footprint. - Slabs are technically present but visually unreadable from side views. - Generated roof caps extend across unrelated lower-floor footprints. - Many columns stand full-height with no upper floor/roof or nearby upper structural support. - Web/digital-twin output has only one heavy GLB when the user requested lightweight download tiers. ## Escalate Beyond Line Extraction Use additional strategies when needed: - Recursive block expansion for `INSERT`. - Hatch boundary extraction for filled wall/slab/column regions. - OCR/title-block reading for floor labels when filenames are ambiguous. - Manual floor split rectangles for complex sheet layouts. - Footprint tuning with wall/glazing/floor-line/railing/column source categories. - Variant generation with `build_showcase_variants.py` before writing the Web viewer. - IFC/BIM generation only after extracted geometry passes showcase-level review. ## BIM Claim Rules Never call the Web showcase a BIM replacement. Call it an IFC/BIM proof only when: - IFC entities exist with storeys and spatial containment. - `IfcWall`, `IfcColumn`, `IfcBeam`, `IfcSlab` counts are reported. - IfcOpenShell geometry generation succeeds or failures are explained. - Remaining gaps are listed: openings, rooms/spaces, doors/windows, quantities, materials, classifications, georeferencing, and coordination. Call it a BIM replacement candidate only after discipline-specific semantic validation, quantity validation, and human review.