fix(modeler): activiti.json 修 Modeler.saveXML 大写元素名(断部署)+真Modeler序列化回归测试

CRITICAL:bpmn-js Modeler.saveXML 把被 activiti.json `extends` 的 bpmn 类型序列化成
PascalCase 元素名(<Process>/<UserTask>/<StartEvent>…),未扩展的 <sequenceFlow>/<endEvent>
仍小写。Flowable 大小写敏感 → <Process> 不被识别为流程,ProcessValidator 报
flowable-process-definition-not-executable,部署完全失败。

根因:moddle 把「被扩展类型」的合并描述符 $pkg 设为**最后一个 trait 的包**(moddle
index.esm.js:577)。activiti 包缺 `xml.tagAlias:"lowerCase"`,故 moddle-xml 写元素名时不做
首字母小写 → PascalCase。且 tagAlias 是**双向**的(也驱动 fromXML 解析),要求自定义元素类型名
用 activiti/camunda 惯例的 PascalCase,否则解析 <activiti:taskListener> 找不到类型而丢弃。

修法(对齐 activiti/camunda-bpmn-moddle 标准):
- activiti.json + flowable.json 加 `"xml": { "tagAlias": "lowerCase" }`;
- 自定义元素类型名改 PascalCase:taskListener→TaskListener / executionListener→ExecutionListener
  / field→Field / formProperty→FormProperty / value→Value / in→In / out→Out(属性 type 引用同步)。
  XML 元素名仍小写(tagAlias),故 fixture 与「toContain('activiti:taskListener')」类 XML 断言不变。
- Eip4Panel.tsx:moddle.create/$type 用 'activiti:TaskListener';测试 fake 类型名同步。

为何旧测试没抓到:T1.1/T1.2 只断言 activiti 扩展属性/元素多重集,从不断言基础 BPMN 元素名大小写;
fromXML→toXML 与 create 都走同一 moddle-xml Writer 且都产 PascalCase(本 commit 实证)。

新增 serialization.test.ts(4 例,RED→GREEN):以 BpmnModdle(= Modeler.saveXML 的 moddle 层,
jsdom 跑不动 diagram-js SVG)驱动 fromXML→toXML 与 create→toXML,断言基础元素名全小写、无 PascalCase、
isExecutable 保留、扩展元素/属性不丢;flowable 隔离同验。

serialization 4 + fidelity 12 + Eip4Panel 37;全量 231 单测绿,tsc -b rc=0 + build 干净。

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-07-02 15:23:51 +08:00
parent 0428a5c9d1
commit 8ea0ef2f1e
6 changed files with 130 additions and 28 deletions

View File

@@ -513,8 +513,8 @@ describe('Eip4Panel — 扩展属性(长尾 $attrs)', () => {
describe('Eip4Panel — 任务监听器(taskListener)', () => { describe('Eip4Panel — 任务监听器(taskListener)', () => {
it('增:新监听器写回 extensionElements,并保留已有监听器的 field(引用不动)', async () => { it('增:新监听器写回 extensionElements,并保留已有监听器的 field(引用不动)', async () => {
const { modeler, updateProperties, moddle, select } = makeModeler(); const { modeler, updateProperties, moddle, select } = makeModeler();
const fieldObj = moddleEl('activiti:field', { name: 'mailTemplate' }); const fieldObj = moddleEl('activiti:Field', { name: 'mailTemplate' });
const existing = moddleEl('activiti:taskListener', { const existing = moddleEl('activiti:TaskListener', {
event: 'complete', event: 'complete',
class: 'com.dsasp.server.wf.user.listener.TaskCompleteListener', class: 'com.dsasp.server.wf.user.listener.TaskCompleteListener',
fields: [fieldObj], fields: [fieldObj],
@@ -543,14 +543,14 @@ describe('Eip4Panel — 任务监听器(taskListener)', () => {
fireEvent.change(screen.getByTestId('eip4-listener-event-0'), { target: { value: 'assignment' } }); fireEvent.change(screen.getByTestId('eip4-listener-event-0'), { target: { value: 'assignment' } });
fireEvent.change(screen.getByTestId('eip4-listener-value-0'), { target: { value: 'com.X.Listener' } }); fireEvent.change(screen.getByTestId('eip4-listener-value-0'), { target: { value: 'com.X.Listener' } });
const ext = lastPayload(updateProperties).extensionElements as { values: Array<Record<string, unknown>> }; const ext = lastPayload(updateProperties).extensionElements as { values: Array<Record<string, unknown>> };
const listener = ext.values.find((v) => v.$type === 'activiti:taskListener')!; const listener = ext.values.find((v) => v.$type === 'activiti:TaskListener')!;
expect(listener.event).toBe('assignment'); expect(listener.event).toBe('assignment');
expect(listener.class).toBe('com.X.Listener'); expect(listener.class).toBe('com.X.Listener');
}); });
it('删:移除唯一监听器 → extensionElements=undefined', async () => { it('删:移除唯一监听器 → extensionElements=undefined', async () => {
const { modeler, updateProperties, select } = makeModeler(); const { modeler, updateProperties, select } = makeModeler();
const existing = moddleEl('activiti:taskListener', { event: 'create', class: 'com.X' }); const existing = moddleEl('activiti:TaskListener', { event: 'create', class: 'com.X' });
render(<Eip4Panel modeler={modeler} />); render(<Eip4Panel modeler={modeler} />);
await select(userTask({ extensionElements: { values: [existing] } })); await select(userTask({ extensionElements: { values: [existing] } }));
fireEvent.click(screen.getByTestId('eip4-listener-remove-0')); fireEvent.click(screen.getByTestId('eip4-listener-remove-0'));
@@ -569,7 +569,7 @@ describe('Eip4Panel — 任务监听器(taskListener)', () => {
}); });
fireEvent.change(screen.getByTestId('eip4-listener-value-0'), { target: { value: '${bean}' } }); fireEvent.change(screen.getByTestId('eip4-listener-value-0'), { target: { value: '${bean}' } });
const ext = lastPayload(updateProperties).extensionElements as { values: Array<Record<string, unknown>> }; const ext = lastPayload(updateProperties).extensionElements as { values: Array<Record<string, unknown>> };
const listener = ext.values.find((v) => v.$type === 'activiti:taskListener')!; const listener = ext.values.find((v) => v.$type === 'activiti:TaskListener')!;
expect(listener.delegateExpression).toBe('${bean}'); expect(listener.delegateExpression).toBe('${bean}');
expect('class' in listener).toBe(false); expect('class' in listener).toBe(false);
}); });

View File

@@ -385,10 +385,13 @@ export function Eip4Panel({ modeler }: { modeler: PanelModeler | null }) {
// 任务监听器 // 任务监听器
const extEl = bo.get('extensionElements') as { values?: unknown[] } | undefined; const extEl = bo.get('extensionElements') as { values?: unknown[] } | undefined;
const values = (extEl?.values ?? []) as unknown[]; const values = (extEl?.values ?? []) as unknown[];
otherExtRef.current = values.filter((v) => (v as { $type?: string }).$type !== 'activiti:taskListener'); // moddle 类型名遵循 activiti/camunda 惯例=PascalCase(xml.tagAlias:lowerCase 令 XML 元素名仍小写
// <activiti:taskListener>),故按 $type 'activiti:TaskListener' 识别;小写名会致扩展类型 $pkg 串味、
// 断部署(见 moddle/serialization.test.ts)。
otherExtRef.current = values.filter((v) => (v as { $type?: string }).$type !== 'activiti:TaskListener');
setListeners( setListeners(
values values
.filter((v) => (v as { $type?: string }).$type === 'activiti:taskListener') .filter((v) => (v as { $type?: string }).$type === 'activiti:TaskListener')
.map((v) => { .map((v) => {
const cls = mget(v, 'class') as string | undefined; const cls = mget(v, 'class') as string | undefined;
const del = mget(v, 'delegateExpression') as string | undefined; const del = mget(v, 'delegateExpression') as string | undefined;
@@ -499,7 +502,7 @@ export function Eip4Panel({ modeler }: { modeler: PanelModeler | null }) {
const props: Record<string, unknown> = { event: l.event }; const props: Record<string, unknown> = { event: l.event };
props[l.mode] = l.value; props[l.mode] = l.value;
if (l.fields && l.fields.length) props.fields = l.fields; if (l.fields && l.fields.length) props.fields = l.fields;
return moddle.create('activiti:taskListener', props); return moddle.create('activiti:TaskListener', props);
}); });
const all = [...otherExtRef.current, ...listenerEls]; const all = [...otherExtRef.current, ...listenerEls];
const extEl = all.length ? moddle.create('bpmn:ExtensionElements', { values: all }) : undefined; const extEl = all.length ? moddle.create('bpmn:ExtensionElements', { values: all }) : undefined;

View File

@@ -2,6 +2,7 @@
"name": "Activiti", "name": "Activiti",
"uri": "http://activiti.org/bpmn", "uri": "http://activiti.org/bpmn",
"prefix": "activiti", "prefix": "activiti",
"xml": { "tagAlias": "lowerCase" },
"associations": [], "associations": [],
"types": [ "types": [
{ {
@@ -90,7 +91,7 @@
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "taskListener", "name": "TaskListener",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"meta": { "allowedIn": ["bpmn:UserTask"] }, "meta": { "allowedIn": ["bpmn:UserTask"] },
"properties": [ "properties": [
@@ -98,11 +99,11 @@
{ "name": "class", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "class", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "expression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "expression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "delegateExpression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "delegateExpression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "fields", "type": "field", "isMany": true } { "name": "fields", "type": "Field", "isMany": true }
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "executionListener", "name": "ExecutionListener",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] }, "meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] },
"properties": [ "properties": [
@@ -110,11 +111,11 @@
{ "name": "class", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "class", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "expression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "expression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "delegateExpression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "delegateExpression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "fields", "type": "field", "isMany": true } { "name": "fields", "type": "Field", "isMany": true }
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "field", "name": "Field",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] }, "meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] },
"properties": [ "properties": [
@@ -125,7 +126,7 @@
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "formProperty", "name": "FormProperty",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] }, "meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] },
"properties": [ "properties": [
@@ -140,11 +141,11 @@
{ "name": "datePattern", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "datePattern", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "default", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "default", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "value", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "value", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "values", "type": "value", "isMany": true } { "name": "values", "type": "Value", "isMany": true }
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "value", "name": "Value",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"properties": [ "properties": [
{ "name": "id", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "id", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
@@ -152,7 +153,7 @@
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "in", "name": "In",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] }, "meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] },
"properties": [ "properties": [
@@ -163,7 +164,7 @@
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "out", "name": "Out",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] }, "meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] },
"properties": [ "properties": [

View File

@@ -37,9 +37,11 @@ function warns(res: any, re: RegExp): any[] {
describe('activiti/flowable moddle 描述符 — 语料覆盖', () => { describe('activiti/flowable moddle 描述符 — 语料覆盖', () => {
it('§0 全部实测 activiti 属性/元素在 activiti.json 有声明', () => { it('§0 全部实测 activiti 属性/元素在 activiti.json 有声明', () => {
const declared = JSON.stringify(activiti); // 大小写不敏感:自定义元素类型名遵循 activiti/camunda 惯例=PascalCase(TaskListener/Field/…),
// xml.tagAlias:lowerCase 令 XML 元素名仍小写(<activiti:taskListener>)。见 serialization.test.ts。
const declared = JSON.stringify(activiti).toLowerCase();
[...CORPUS_ATTRS, ...CORPUS_ELEMENTS].forEach((n) => [...CORPUS_ATTRS, ...CORPUS_ELEMENTS].forEach((n) =>
expect(declared, `activiti:${n} 未声明`).toContain(`"${n}"`)); expect(declared, `activiti:${n} 未声明`).toContain(`"${n.toLowerCase()}"`));
}); });
it('flowable.json 声明命名空间与 flowable:assignee', () => { it('flowable.json 声明命名空间与 flowable:assignee', () => {
@@ -85,14 +87,14 @@ describe('activiti round-trip 零丢失(合成 fixture 覆盖全扩展面)',
const { rootElement } = await newActiviti().fromXML(SYNTHETIC_BPMN); const { rootElement } = await newActiviti().fromXML(SYNTHETIC_BPMN);
const receive = findById(rootElement, 't_receive'); const receive = findById(rootElement, 't_receive');
const listener = receive.extensionElements.values.find( const listener = receive.extensionElements.values.find(
(v: any) => v.$type === 'activiti:taskListener', (v: any) => v.$type === 'activiti:TaskListener',
); );
expect(listener.event).toBe('complete'); expect(listener.event).toBe('complete');
expect(listener.class).toBe('com.dsasp.server.wf.user.listener.TaskCompleteListener'); expect(listener.class).toBe('com.dsasp.server.wf.user.listener.TaskCompleteListener');
expect(listener.fields[0].name).toBe('mailTemplate'); expect(listener.fields[0].name).toBe('mailTemplate');
expect(listener.fields[0].string).toBe('审批完成通知'); expect(listener.fields[0].string).toBe('审批完成通知');
const formProp = receive.extensionElements.values.find( const formProp = receive.extensionElements.values.find(
(v: any) => v.$type === 'activiti:formProperty', (v: any) => v.$type === 'activiti:FormProperty',
); );
expect(formProp.id).toBe('fp_remark'); expect(formProp.id).toBe('fp_remark');
expect(formProp.values.map((v: any) => v.name)).toEqual(['同意', '驳回']); expect(formProp.values.map((v: any) => v.name)).toEqual(['同意', '驳回']);

View File

@@ -2,6 +2,7 @@
"name": "Flowable", "name": "Flowable",
"uri": "http://flowable.org/bpmn", "uri": "http://flowable.org/bpmn",
"prefix": "flowable", "prefix": "flowable",
"xml": { "tagAlias": "lowerCase" },
"associations": [], "associations": [],
"types": [ "types": [
{ {
@@ -44,7 +45,7 @@
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "taskListener", "name": "TaskListener",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"meta": { "allowedIn": ["bpmn:UserTask"] }, "meta": { "allowedIn": ["bpmn:UserTask"] },
"properties": [ "properties": [
@@ -52,11 +53,11 @@
{ "name": "class", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "class", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "expression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "expression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "delegateExpression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "delegateExpression", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "fields", "type": "field", "isMany": true } { "name": "fields", "type": "Field", "isMany": true }
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "field", "name": "Field",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] }, "meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] },
"properties": [ "properties": [
@@ -67,7 +68,7 @@
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "formProperty", "name": "FormProperty",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] }, "meta": { "allowedIn": ["*"] },
"properties": [ "properties": [
@@ -75,11 +76,11 @@
{ "name": "name", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "name", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "type", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "type", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "required", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "required", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },
{ "name": "values", "type": "value", "isMany": true } { "name": "values", "type": "Value", "isMany": true }
] ]
}, },
{ {
"name": "value", "name": "Value",
"superClass": ["Element"], "superClass": ["Element"],
"properties": [ "properties": [
{ "name": "id", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" }, { "name": "id", "isAttr": true, "type": "String" },

View File

@@ -0,0 +1,95 @@
import { describe, it, expect } from 'vitest';
import BpmnModdle from 'bpmn-moddle';
import activiti from './activiti.json';
import flowable from './flowable.json';
import { SYNTHETIC_BPMN } from './fixtures/synthetic-full-surface.bpmn';
// 元素名大小写回归(CRITICAL:断部署)。
//
// 根因:moddle 把「被扩展类型」的合并描述符 $pkg 设为**最后一个 trait 的包**
// (moddle index.esm.js:577)。activiti.json 用 `extends` 给 bpmn:Process/UserTask/StartEvent…
// 加属性 → 这些基础类型的 $pkg 变成 activiti 包;moddle-xml 序列化时按 $pkg 的
// `xml.tagAlias` 决定元素名首字母是否小写。bpmn 包有 `tagAlias:"lowerCase"`(Process→process),
// activiti 包若无此声明 → 写出 PascalCase `<Process>/<UserTask>/<StartEvent>`。
// **Flowable 大小写敏感**:`<Process>` 不被识别为流程 → 部署时 ProcessValidator 报
// flowable-process-definition-not-executable(看到 0 个可执行流程),部署完全失败。
//
// 为何 T1.1/T1.2 没抓到:它们只断言 activiti 扩展属性/元素多重集,**从不断言基础 BPMN 元素名的
// 大小写**;且 fromXML→toXML 与 create 都走同一 moddle-xml Writer,均产 PascalCase(本文件实证)。
//
// 为何用 BpmnModdle 而非真 Modeler:bpmn-js Modeler 依赖 diagram-js 的 SVG 布局(getBBox 等),
// jsdom 跑不动;而 Modeler.saveXML 在 moddle 层就是 `moddle.toXML(定义树)`,diagram-js 从不改元素名。
// 故 `new BpmnModdle({activiti})` 的 fromXML→toXML / create→toXML 忠实复现 saveXML 的元素命名路径。
const BASE_TYPES: Array<[create: string, lower: string, pascal: string]> = [
['bpmn:Process', 'process', 'Process'],
['bpmn:UserTask', 'userTask', 'UserTask'],
['bpmn:StartEvent', 'startEvent', 'StartEvent'],
['bpmn:ScriptTask', 'scriptTask', 'ScriptTask'],
['bpmn:EndEvent', 'endEvent', 'EndEvent'],
['bpmn:SequenceFlow', 'sequenceFlow', 'SequenceFlow'],
['bpmn:BoundaryEvent', 'boundaryEvent', 'BoundaryEvent'],
];
/** 元素名正则(可选 bpmn: 前缀 + 精确 token + 分隔符),大小写敏感。 */
const openTag = (name: string) => new RegExp('<(bpmn:)?' + name + '[\\s/>]');
describe('moddle 序列化——基础 BPMN 元素名小写(断部署回归)', () => {
it('打开存量再导出(fromXML→toXML):基础元素名全小写,无 PascalCase(Flowable 可识别)', async () => {
const moddle = new BpmnModdle({ activiti });
const { rootElement } = await moddle.fromXML(SYNTHETIC_BPMN);
const { xml } = await moddle.toXML(rootElement, { format: true });
for (const [, lower, pascal] of BASE_TYPES) {
expect(xml, `应含小写 <${lower}>`).toMatch(openTag(lower));
expect(xml, `不应含 PascalCase <${pascal}>(Flowable 大小写敏感)`).not.toMatch(openTag(pascal));
}
});
it('isExecutable 症状:process 元素小写且保留 isExecutable="true"', async () => {
const moddle = new BpmnModdle({ activiti });
const { rootElement } = await moddle.fromXML(SYNTHETIC_BPMN);
const { xml } = await moddle.toXML(rootElement, { format: true });
// 真正的 bug 是 <Process> 不被识别("isExecutable 丢失"只是症状)——断言 process 小写即可。
expect(xml).toMatch(/<(bpmn:)?process[\s][^>]*isExecutable="true"/);
expect(xml).not.toMatch(openTag('Process'));
});
it('新建元素(create→toXML):新建流程各基础节点名也全小写', async () => {
const moddle = new BpmnModdle({ activiti });
const defs = moddle.create('bpmn:Definitions', { targetNamespace: 'http://x' });
const proc = moddle.create('bpmn:Process', { id: 'p1', isExecutable: true });
const start = moddle.create('bpmn:StartEvent', { id: 's1' });
const ut = moddle.create('bpmn:UserTask', {
id: 't1',
'activiti:candidateUsers': 'X',
'activiti:formKey': 'K',
});
const flow = moddle.create('bpmn:SequenceFlow', { id: 'f1', sourceRef: start, targetRef: ut });
const end = moddle.create('bpmn:EndEvent', { id: 'e1' });
proc.flowElements = [start, ut, flow, end];
defs.rootElements = [proc];
const { xml } = await moddle.toXML(defs, { format: true });
for (const [, lower, pascal] of BASE_TYPES.filter(([, l]) => l !== 'scriptTask' && l !== 'boundaryEvent')) {
expect(xml, `应含小写 <${lower}>`).toMatch(openTag(lower));
expect(xml, `不应含 PascalCase <${pascal}>`).not.toMatch(openTag(pascal));
}
// 扩展属性 / 自定义元素不受影响
expect(xml).toContain('activiti:candidateUsers="X"');
expect(xml).toContain('activiti:formKey="K"');
});
it('flowable 描述符隔离同样小写(虽不进 Modeler,防同类潜伏 bug)', async () => {
const moddle = new BpmnModdle({ flowable });
const defs = moddle.create('bpmn:Definitions', { targetNamespace: 'http://x' });
const proc = moddle.create('bpmn:Process', { id: 'p1', isExecutable: true });
const ut = moddle.create('bpmn:UserTask', { id: 't1', 'flowable:assignee': 'u1' });
proc.flowElements = [ut];
defs.rootElements = [proc];
const { xml } = await moddle.toXML(defs, { format: true });
expect(xml).toMatch(openTag('process'));
expect(xml).toMatch(openTag('userTask'));
expect(xml).not.toMatch(openTag('Process'));
expect(xml).not.toMatch(openTag('UserTask'));
expect(xml).toContain('flowable:assignee="u1"');
});
});